Key Researchers


Overview of Cost-Effectiveness of Substance Abuse Treatment in Criminal Justice Settings


Kathryn McCollister, Ph.D., University of Miami Miller School of Medicine

Review Panel: Steven Belenko, Ph.D., Temple University, Matt Hiller, Ph.D., Temple University, Michael Prendergast, Ph.D., UCLA
Introduction: The unfortunate synergy between criminal activity and drug use persists as a major challenge to public health and public safety systems. Today, half of the 2 million people incarcerated in state and federal prisons meet the criteria for drug dependence or abuse as described in the most recent edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) (Mumola and Karberg, 2006; Belenko and Peugh, 2005).

Although the prevalence of drug dependence or abuse is highest among offenders committing non-violent drug-related crimes, an estimated 25% of state and federal prisoners report committing violent offenses while being under the influence of drugs. Violent crimes include such offenses as rape/sexual assault, aggravated assault, and murder, which represent the most costly of all crimes with an estimated cost per offense ranging between $127,000 to over $8 million (Rajkumar and French, 1997; Miller, Cohen, and Rossman, 1993).

The annual growth rate in incarceration has slowed in recent years, but expenditures for criminal justice services (police, courts, corrections) have increased (Bureau of Justice Statistics [BJS], 2004). Furthermore, as a proportion of their respective budgets, states are spending more on criminal justice functions than the federal government (BJS, 2004). Because departments of correction represent such a large component of most state budgets, it is particularly important to evaluate funding priorities and to suggest better ways of allocating correctional resources. The prevalence of drug use among criminal offenders and the positive rate of growth in the already large incarcerated population strongly suggest a need to fund cost-effective substance abuse interventions in criminal justice settings.

Date Updated : Aug. 2009
Original Date: Jul. 2008

McCollister, K.E.; Cost Effectiveness of Substance Abuse Treatment in Criminal Justice Settings Knowledge Asset, Web site created by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation's Substance Abuse Policy Research Program; August 2009.,

Who We Are  | SAPRP Staff | Click here to receive updates when new Knowledge Assets are posted

SAPRP . One Leadership Place . Greensboro, NC 27410 . P: 336.286.4548 . F: 336.286.4434

A National Program supported by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation with direction and technical assistance provided by the Center for Creative Leadership.
SAPRP Home SAPRP Knowledge Assets Home